A Novel Approach to Quantify Counter-Drone System Effectiveness Against UAS Swarms

A Novel Approach to Quantify Counter-Drone System Effectiveness Against UAS Swarms

Dani HOTTERS, Nikolaos KALLIATAKIS, Felix KUHNERT, Prajwal Shiva PRAKASHA, Ries VAN HEUR, Buse KAYA

Abstract. Swarm attacks composed of Unmanned Aerial System (UAS) have rapidly evolved into a sophisticated and constantly evolving threat to modern air defense strategies. By exploiting overwhelming numbers, high agility, and a coordinated behavior, drone swarms are able to penetrate and overwhelm traditional, multi-layered, defense architectures. Recent conflicts have highlighted critical vulnerabilities and challenges in maintaining robust defense and deterrence postures against drone swarms. As counter-UAS technologies, systems, and Concepts of Operations (CONOPS) continue to evolve, a method to evaluate their effectiveness and to quantify their relative performance becomes crucial. This paper details the adaptation of an agent-based modeling and simulation environment, developed by the German Aerospace Centre (DLR), to assess the operational performance of counter-UAS architectures from a holistic System of Systems (SoS) perspective. To address the computational challenges of large-scale swarm engagements, the approach integrates surrogate models informed by high-fidelity (hi-fi) simulations, into low-fidelity (lo-fi) models to approximate the behavior of counter-UAS systems, thereby enabling scalability and simulation on the theater scale. Combined with well-defined Measures of Effectiveness (MoEs), this methodology provides a novel approach for comparing counter-UAS solutions. It provides stakeholders and decision-makers with the information needed to evaluate system performance and make informed decisions in shaping future air defense strategies and architectures.

Keywords
Unmanned Aerial Systems, Drone Swarms, Agent-Based Simulation, Multi-Agent Systems, Requirements, System of Systems, Performance Analysis, Counter-UAS Systems, Defense

Published online 7/20/2026, 5 pages
Copyright © 2026 by the author(s)
Published under license by Materials Research Forum LLC., Millersville PA, USA

Citation: Dani HOTTERS, Nikolaos KALLIATAKIS, Felix KUHNERT, Prajwal Shiva PRAKASHA, Ries VAN HEUR, Buse KAYA, A Novel Approach to Quantify Counter-Drone System Effectiveness Against UAS Swarms, Materials Research Proceedings, Vol. 69, pp 856-860, 2026

DOI: https://doi.org/10.21741/9781644904251-151

The article was published as article 151 of the book CEAS – AIDAA Conference 2025

Content from this work may be used under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 license. Any further distribution of this work must maintain attribution to the author(s) and the title of the work, journal citation and DOI.

References
[1] T. Ditter, E. Harvey, PRC Concepts for UAV Swarms in Future Warfare, CNA Corporation, 2025
[2] U. Azmi, Y. Ruyat, L.A. Affandi, Defence and Security System Against The Threat of Drone Weapons In The Oil and Gas Industry As a Vital National Object, The Republic of Indonesia defense University, 2024
[3] S. Crino, C. Dreby, Drone Attacks Against Critical Infrastructure: A Real and Present Threat, Atlantic Council, 2020
[4] O. Molloy, Drones in Modern Warfare: Lessons Learnt from the War in Ukraine, Australian Army Occasional Paper No. 29, 2024 https://doi.org/10.61451/267513
[5] S. Kilkis, N. Naeem, P.S. Prakasha, A Python Modelling and Simulation Toolkit for Rapid Development of System of Systems Inverse Design (SoSID) Case Studies, DLR, AIAA Aviation 2021 Forum https://doi.org/10.2514/6.2021-3000
[6] J. Seethaler, M. Strohal, P. Stütz, Finding Metrics For Combat Aircraft Mission Efficiency: An AHP-Based Approach, DLR, DLRK 2020